Dinning on Shelter Island NY.

jhofmann

Does anyone know where we can dine by boat on Shelter Island, NY?

aero3113

http://www.saltshelterisland.com

TonyWalker

Try Claudio's  They have a dock and sea wall and is easy to get to.  Also the food is good in my opinion, as well as others.

Tony Walker

Salt Shaker 342

Claudio's Restaurant

111 Main St, Greenport, NY 11944 · Greenport

(631) 477-0627 · $$$ · Seafood

jhofmann

Yes, I have been to Claudio's a number of times, and it is good, but I was looking for someplace different, and on Shelter Island itself. I see on trip advisor there are over 20 places to dine, but I don't know if you can access any by boat. 

aero3113

My wife's family owns a house on Shelter Island, we got married on the island and had our reception on the property. We visit there often and recently went to a restaurant called Salt,it's accessible by water and was very good.

jhofmann

Thanks aero3113, I read about Salt and it sounds good.

aero3113

No problem, there is Sunset Beach also, great restaurant but call and and ask if they have docks for visitors (you might have to anchor)

aero3113

LoL, no that was Shutter Island!

Michael T

x

aero3113

jhoffman, did you ever make it to Shelter Island? I just remembered this post, would like to hear your reviews!

jhofmann

No, on my first attempt my outdrive went just the other side of plum gut, and I had to be towed back to the Connecticut river. The next time was a couple weeks ago, and since it was late in the season, we went where we knew would be open, Claudio's. Great Manhattan clam chowder. The goal is to make it to Salt next year.