Battery 1 Not Charging
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/72383/72383c8e47980077ba25aefd8b883cc51bce4573" alt="alger34"
Hey guy's, I have an 07 250 Fiesta Vee with 350 merc. My number 1 battery does not charge on the alternator, charges fine on shore power, (both batteries brand new this year) but my number 2 battery shows almost 14 volts on dash and charges fine, (ran my boat all weekend). I removed battery terminal and cleaned it up with no luck. There is a melted cap on what appears to be the voltage regulator maybe? It has 3 red caps and is mounted on the firewall forward of the engine. Is this most likely my issue? Thanks.
Comments
Go Steelers!!!