Thanks @Aqua_Aura That's a 1999-2001 model like I had and I can tell you that nub of a swim platform is essentially hollow inside. Hope they braced it up. Also curious as to how the steering works....
I saw a nice new 270'ish size going down the road heading to the daytona area...out boards. It just foes not look right...it's not the yacht look of a boat to me. I'm sure it's a sweet boat.
I'll go out on a limb here: I think it's ignorant and dangerous. <EDIT: Later I realized this comment was poorly written, and I rewrote it as follows: If the mod was done in ignorance of the effects on stability, it's potentially dangerous. >
For a 270 hull, the stability calculations assume the engine's weight is below the waterline. That's how it's designed. If you move that 1000 pounds of mass two feet ABOVE the waterline, the boat will roll like a pig and be more prone to capsizing. And because it's so far back, the boat will be prone to swamping in following seas.
Looks like any jackwagon with fiberglass and a mold can build and sell rec boats in the US. And if you own a rec boat, nothing prevents you from making bad decisions about it.
A few things are regulated, such as documentation and nav lights. Stability and overloading are not regulated.
I'll go out on a limb here: I think it's ignorant and dangerous.
For a 270 hull, the stability calculations assume the engine's weight is below the waterline. That's how it's designed. If you move that 1000 pounds of mass two feet ABOVE the waterline, the boat will roll like a pig and be more prone to capsizing. And because it's so far back, the boat will be prone to swamping in following seas.
I agree, I’m thinking that’s the maiden voyage. I want to know if it made it back to the ramp!?
Ok, maybe I shouldn't comment this time of night, but I think both ignorant AND dangerous? Come on Chris! We don't know the entire circumstance of what's going on. As someone with a BSEE, MSEE, MSME, MSSE....well, I think it's something that hey, maybe they're trying it out. First, with motors moved back, bow would stay down. Sure the CG would change. Inertia and steering pivot point would change. If I were to put it in a CAD model, I don't believe there would be any chance of rolling, let alone flipping. Following seas? I don't know, I think you may be surprised. It looks like something I'd love to do if I had the time. Now, this is not saying I like outdrives on the back of my cruiser! Far from it and I love my platform way too much. It would be a fun project though to compare it between a model and real life. OK, back to watching my Paralympics hockey for gold medal. Go USA!
Haha -- @Dream_Inn you are right. I should have said: <If> the mod was done in ignorance of the effects on stability, it's <potentially> dangerous.
My boat weighs 10 tons, and I can affect the running angle by relocating a 50-pound cooler. A 270 weighs only 4 tons, and they relocated 1000 pounds. That's 13% of the boat's weight.
Most Rinker cruisers will swamp the swim platform if you're on plane and you cut the throttle. Well, imagine doing that after moving 1000 pounds from the engine room back onto the swim platform. You'll probably swamp the whole cockpit.
Same with roll stability. If you move 13% of the boat's weight 3-4 feet higher, that's a big deal. Hull shapes are designed based on the weight and location of the machinery.
The boats look the same to me from the waterline up but I don't know for sure. The pics of the 42 XO show the engine room repurposed as a giant storage space.
I don't think boat building is anything like automotive - vehicles are so heavily regulated in all aspects. Boats, it seems like all you need is a HIN code, some warning labels and coast guard approved lighting.
Another consideration is insurance. The policy was probably issued assuming it's a production boat. Removing the boat's engine and installing outdrives would almost certainly void the insurance.
But -- it gave us something interesting to talk about on an abbreviated "spring ahead" Sunday morning!
Comments
2018 Cherokee 39RL Land Yacht (Sorry...)
That's a 1999-2001 model like I had and I can tell you that nub of a swim platform is essentially hollow inside. Hope they braced it up. Also curious as to how the steering works....
2018 Cherokee 39RL Land Yacht (Sorry...)
<EDIT: Later I realized this comment was poorly written, and I rewrote it as follows: If the mod was done in ignorance of the effects on stability, it's potentially dangerous. >
For a 270 hull, the stability calculations assume the engine's weight is below the waterline. That's how it's designed. If you move that 1000 pounds of mass two feet ABOVE the waterline, the boat will roll like a pig and be more prone to capsizing. And because it's so far back, the boat will be prone to swamping in following seas.
Edit: I went down this rabbit hole. Maybe you can, too! https://newboatbuilders.com/pages/index2.html
A few things are regulated, such as documentation and nav lights. Stability and overloading are not regulated.
Dream 'Inn III -- 2008 400 Express
My boat weighs 10 tons, and I can affect the running angle by relocating a 50-pound cooler. A 270 weighs only 4 tons, and they relocated 1000 pounds. That's 13% of the boat's weight.
Most Rinker cruisers will swamp the swim platform if you're on plane and you cut the throttle. Well, imagine doing that after moving 1000 pounds from the engine room back onto the swim platform. You'll probably swamp the whole cockpit.
Same with roll stability. If you move 13% of the boat's weight 3-4 feet higher, that's a big deal. Hull shapes are designed based on the weight and location of the machinery.
Anyway, the empty engine bay would be a great place for a Seakeeper!
https://www.regalboats.com/fleet-search/
https://www.boatingmag.com/four-winns-vista-355-boat-test/
I don't think boat building is anything like automotive - vehicles are so heavily regulated in all aspects. Boats, it seems like all you need is a HIN code, some warning labels and coast guard approved lighting.
Another consideration is insurance. The policy was probably issued assuming it's a production boat. Removing the boat's engine and installing outdrives would almost certainly void the insurance.
But -- it gave us something interesting to talk about on an abbreviated "spring ahead" Sunday morning!